REPORTS OF CASES

DETERMINED IN

THE DISTRICT COURTS OF APPEAL

OF THE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

C. P. POMEROY

REPORTER

H. L. GEAR

ASSISTANT REPORTER

VOLUME 23

SAN FRANCISCO
BANCROFT-WHITNEY COMPANY

1914

COPYRIGHT, 1914

BY

BANCROFT-WHITNEY COMPANY

JURISPRUDENCE

SAN FRANCISCO
THE FILMER BROTHERS ELECTROTYPE COMPANY
TYPOGRAPHERS AND STEREOTYPERS

DISTRICT COURTS OF APPEAL.

FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT.

THOS. J. LENNON, Presiding Justice.
FRANK H. KERRIGAN, Associate Justice.
JOHN E. RICHARDS, Associate Justice.

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT.

MATTHEW T. ALLEN, Presiding Justice.1
N. P. CONREY, Presiding Justice."

W. P. JAMES, Associate Justice.

VICTOR E. SHAW, Associate Justice.

THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT.

N. P. CHIPMAN, Presiding Justice.
ELIJAH C. HART, Associate Justice.

ALBERT G. BURNETT, Associate Justice.

1 Died, October 10, 1913.

2 Appointed, October 18, 1913, in place of Hon. Matthew T. Allen, deceased.

(iii)

898561