Dispute Settlement Reports 2001: Volume 1, Pages 1-409World Trade Organization Cambridge University Press, 2003 M06 26 - 412 pages The Dispute Settlement Reports of the World Trade Organization (WTO) include Panel and Appellate Body reports, as well as arbitration awards, in disputes concerning the rights and obligations of WTO members under the provisions of the Marrakesh Agreement. These are the WTO authorized and paginated reports in English. An essential addition to the library of all practising and academic trade lawyers, and needed by students worldwide taking courses in international economic or trade law. The form of citation for this volume recommended by the WTO is DSR 2001: I. |
Contents
Report of the Appellate Body | 10 |
ISSUES RAISED IN THIS APPEAL | 23 |
A Koreas Commitment Levels for 1997 and 1998 | 29 |
DUAL RETAIL SYSTEM | 40 |
Report of the Appellate Body 5 | 44 |
FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS | 57 |
Report of the Panel | 59 |
11 | 67 |
17 | 136 |
17 | 144 |
18 | 152 |
A Korea Appellant | 157 |
The Panel concluded that certain of the measures at issue are included | 261 |
and cannot be justified pursuant to Article XXd of the GATT 1994 that | 287 |
and thus benefit from a transitional period until 1 January 2001 by which date | 331 |
posed on domestic beef such as the requirement that the endconsumer the con | 332 |
ing on Rules and Procedures Governing the Settlement of Disputes the DSU | 82 |
1 III4 XI1 and XVII of the GATT 1994 that discharge pro | 84 |
ARGUMENTS OF THE PARTICIPANTS AND THE THIRD | 92 |
133 | 94 |
Panel Report Korea Measures Affecting Imports of Fresh Chilled and Frozen Beef Korea | 100 |
United States Import Measures on Certain Products | 373 |
The Panel recommended that the Dispute Settlement Body DSB | 375 |
Pursuant to Rule 211 of the Working Procedures | 377 |
Panel Report Korea Various Measures on Beef supra footnote 1 para 49 | 396 |
Common terms and phrases
accordance Agreement on Agriculture Alcoholic Beverages AMS for beef Annex Appellate Body Report arguments Article 3.2 Article III:4 Article XI Article XI:1 Article XX(d Australia submitted beef imported billion won calculation cattle cent claims commitment levels Complaining parties contrary to Article Current AMS Current Total AMS dispute domestic beef domestic products domestic support dual retail system eligible production end-users European Communities external reference price fixed external reference footnote grass-fed beef Hanwoo import restrictions imported beef stores imported products imposed inconsistent with Article Korea argues Korea submitted Korea's Schedule Korean beef LPMO LPMO's mark-up market price support Members NLCF Note 6(e obligations Panel report paragraph ported beef purchase quantitative restrictions quota share Records of Understanding regulations remaining restrictions requirement ROUS sale of imported SBS system Schedule LX selling imported beef specific super-groups support for beef tenders tion tonnes trade Unfair Competition Act Uruguay Round violation of Article Zealand