Accountable Aid: Local Participation in Major ProjectsOxfam, 1998 - 176 pages The Earth Summit in Rio in 1992 generated much rhetoric about the need for collaboration between local communities and multilateral funders of major development projects, in order to preserve natural resources. Since then there has been intense debate about the importance of local participation, accountability to local communities, transparent procedures and gender-sensitive planning. In this work, the author examines the case of the Rondonia Natural Resource Management Project (PLANAFLORO) in the Amazon, funded by the World Bank, and considers the frustrations created when local NGOs and communities were effectively excluded from decisions about a project that claimed to be participatory. In contrast, she considers examples of relatively good practice, most notably the Joint Forest Management project, funded by the British Overseas Development Administration, in Karnataka, India. The author also examines recent atttempts by the World Bank to involve local governments in decision making. From a focus on individual projects, the book moves to a consideration of local participation in entire projects - the World Bank's Country Assistance Strategies - and community involvement in projects funded by the private sector. It ends with a summary of the lessons to be learned by local and international NGOs and by major donors. |
From inside the book
Results 1-5 of 33
Page 4
... PLANAFLORO , the Rondônia Natural Resource Management Project , which was initiated in Brazil in 1992. Early field work was done in 1994 in collaboration with the agronomist Mario Menezes and the anthropologist Mario Silva . An interim ...
... PLANAFLORO , the Rondônia Natural Resource Management Project , which was initiated in Brazil in 1992. Early field work was done in 1994 in collaboration with the agronomist Mario Menezes and the anthropologist Mario Silva . An interim ...
Page 15
... ( PLANAFLORO ) in the State of Rondônia , Brazil . The Bank announced that it had embarked on a process of ' learning better how to promote popular participation , learning from some excep- tionally participatory Bank - financed projects ...
... ( PLANAFLORO ) in the State of Rondônia , Brazil . The Bank announced that it had embarked on a process of ' learning better how to promote popular participation , learning from some excep- tionally participatory Bank - financed projects ...
Page 29
... PLANAFLORO , largely failed at least in its initial phases - to promote a participatory approach to sustainable development . Rondônia : State , society , and frontier expansion Until the arrival of Europeans in the seventeenth century ...
... PLANAFLORO , largely failed at least in its initial phases - to promote a participatory approach to sustainable development . Rondônia : State , society , and frontier expansion Until the arrival of Europeans in the seventeenth century ...
Page 35
... PLANAFLORO . The official agencies responsible for implementing the programme had little autonomy of action . They were in thrall to local economically powerful elites who were able to exercise enormous influence over the use of project ...
... PLANAFLORO . The official agencies responsible for implementing the programme had little autonomy of action . They were in thrall to local economically powerful elites who were able to exercise enormous influence over the use of project ...
Page 40
... PLANAFLORO and the struggle for participation PLANAFLORO , the follow - up project to POLONOROESTE , was a ' child of Rio ' , in so far as it was publicly launched by the World Bank just before the Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro in 1992 ...
... PLANAFLORO and the struggle for participation PLANAFLORO , the follow - up project to POLONOROESTE , was a ' child of Rio ' , in so far as it was publicly launched by the World Bank just before the Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro in 1992 ...
Other editions - View all
Common terms and phrases
ACP Countries action plan activities agencies agricultural assessments Bank's beneficiaries benefits Board Brazil Brazilian government Bugangaizi cent co-operation Commission Committee communities complaints concerns conservation consultation countries decentralisation decisions deforestation displacement donors Earth Summit economic effective ensure environmental European European Commission European Development Fund European Parliament European Union Evaluation Report evictions finance forest areas Forest Department forest reserves Forestry Project funds Game Corridor groups guidelines human rights impact implementation improve INCRA Indian indigenous Inspection Panel institutions International involuntary resettlement JFPM Kampala Karnataka Kibale Forest land loan Lomé Lomé Convention monitoring natural resources needs NGOs NTFP official organisations Oxfam Oxfam UK participation participatory approaches PLANAFLORO plantations political POLONOROESTE poor population Porto Velho poverty priorities problems procedures promote recognised responsibility Rondônia rubber-tappers rural settlers social staff stakeholders strategy sustainable Uganda Uttara Kannada villages Western Ghats WGFP women World Bank zoning
Popular passages
Page 12 - Developed countries members of the Development Assistance Committee of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development...
Page 148 - Environmental issues are best handled with the participation of all concerned citizens, at the relevant level. At the national level, each individual shall have appropriate access to information concerning the environment that is held by public authorities, including information on hazardous materials and activities in their communities, and the opportunity to participate in decision-making...
Page 13 - Governance is defined as the manner in which power is exercised in the management of a country's economic and social resources.
Page 127 - alleged contraventions or maladministration in the implementation of Community law...
Page 148 - The human person is the central subject of development and should be the active participant and beneficiary of the right to development.
Page 22 - ... constraints to a minimum, the effective functioning of the Bank necessarily requires some derogation from complete openness. 50. Proceedings of the Board of Executive Directors and committees thereof are, under the Board's Rules of Procedure, confidential. Thus, unless disclosure is approved by the Board, documents prepared for the consideration or review and approval of the Executive Directors, such as President's Reports and Memoranda of the President for proposed loans and credits, and Operations...
Page 15 - learning process" on participatory development, defined as "a process through which stakeholders influence and share control over development initiatives, and the decisions and resources which affect them".
Page 124 - ... having its own legitimacy; non-discriminatory treatment: fundamental human rights; civil and political rights; economic, social and cultural rights. Every individual shall have the right, in his own country or in a host country, to respect for his dignity and protection by the law. ACP-EEC co-operation shall help abolish the obstacles preventing individuals and peoples from actually enjoying to the full their economic, social and cultural rights and this must be achieved through the development...
Page 156 - Evaluation of EU Aid to ACP Countries Managed by the Commission: Phase 1 Report'.
Page 125 - Convention and to facilitate the pursuit of its objectives. They shall refrain from any measures liable to jeopardise the attainment of the objectives of this Convention.