Page images
PDF
EPUB

remaining in college is not so clear. Leighton is somewhat contradictory on this point. On the one hand, she notes that students from uneducated families do as well as those from educated families, once they do enter (p. 296). On the other hand, she finds that having at least one parent with a minimum level of an eighth-grade education is positively related to successful completion of a college course (p. 314). The conclusions she draws from her data call for clarification. Elsewhere in her study, however, she demonstrates the impact of family organization on academic success. "There were more students who graduated from secure, consanguineal families with an understanding of a need for education, than from similarly secure families without the understanding of this need for education and its problems" (p. 289). Furthermore, she found that the values of a secure membership in a Navaho nuclear family appear to make dropping out more probable when family demands are made on the student (p. 331). No doubt the family has a profound influence upon one's college career.

Hamblin (235), using data from a questionnaire administered to Apache and Navaho high school seniors, also demonstrated the importance of the family in creating a desire to undertake higher education. In this case the students reported that they received the most encouragement from their parents, with only limited encouragement from teachers and friends. Whether or not this encouragement actually resulted in college entrance is not explored in this study.

McGrath and Quimby also report that the parents' attitudes are definitely related to a student's success in college. Quimby says, in fact, that the attitude of parents is one of the most decisive factors in discriminating between successful and unsuccessful college students (p. 83). McGrath, too, indicates a definite relationship between grades and the attitudes of parents. His findings, however, are not exactly what one might anticipate. Says he, "Only 36 percent of those students whose parents actively encourage them in their college education achieve a grade point average of 2 or higher, while 51 percent of those students whose parents are reported to be pleased but not actively encouraging their children in college earn a 2 or better grade average.' McGrath interprets this to mean that "many Indian students are in college because their parents wish them to continue their education rather than because of any real desire on their own part. Those whose parents are pleased but not actively encouraging them may be the ones who are really interested in bettering themselves through education" (p. 252).

The fact remains that parents' attitudes affect college performance. Of all the cases reviewed by McGrath, there was not one instance of a successful student coming from a home where parents actively discouraged college attendance, and there was only one case on record of a successful student coming from a home where parents were displeased but did not actively discourage attendance.

Tribal, as well as parental, encouragement may also be related to success in college. This relationship has been explored by both Nix and McGrath. Both studies, as indicated earlier in this chapter, extensively review the numerous programs, financial and otherwise, which tribes have established to encourage higher education. The McGrath study examines the programs set up by 37 tribes in the

Southwest, whereby scholarships, loans, summer employment, and so forth, are made available to college students. Nix studied the activities of 13 Arizona Indian groups, and found that many of them provide scholarships, make educational loans, provide employment during vacations, furnish books and clothing, offer guidance and counseling, and in various other ways try to encourage their youths to attend college.

What relationship this encouragement bears to college success, however, remains an open question. While Nix found that increase of tribal scholarships has led to an increase in college attendance, he could not draw definite conclusions regarding the effect of these programs on academic achievement. For one thing, many of the programs are too recent to permit such an analysis; and, furthermore, many factors other than tribal encouragement are related to academic success, and it has been impossible to control these other factors so as to isolate the effects of tribal encouragement. McGrath, too, failed to draw definite conclusions regarding the impact of these programs. Interviews with tribal leaders, however, indicated that they were convinced that such encouragement was important. Thirty-eight percent of all tribal leaders interviewed, in fact, identified lack of encouragement from family and tribe as a major cause of dropping out. And a full 55 percent of these leaders believe that the way to help Indian students succeed in college is to "keep in touch with them and let them know that the tribe cares."

In summary, it can be said that Indian college students, on the whole, do not do well in college. There are many reasons for this failure. Some of these, such as limited or faulty educational background have been rather thoroughly explored. Others, such as cultural, situational, and personality factors call for further study.

REFERENCES

1. Ablon, Joan. "Relocated American Indians in the San Francisco

Bay Area." Human Organization, XXXIII:4:296–304, Winter. 1964.

1965.

2. Ablon, Joan. "American Indian Relocation: Problems of Dependency and Management in the City." Phylon, XXVI:362–371, 3. Abrahams, Ina. "Vocational Interest of Selected Indian College Students as Measured by the Kuder Preference Record." Journal of American Indian Education, II:1:20-24, October, 1962. 4. Adair, John J. A Study of Culture Resistance: The Veterans of World War II at Zuni Pueblo. Ph. D., University of New Mexico, 1948.

5. Adair, Mildred L. The Establishment, Growth, Development, and Functioning of the Federal Day School on the Navaho Reservation Since 1935. M.A., Florida State University, 1938. 6. Adams, Evelyn C. American Indian Education: Government Schools and Economic Progress. King's Crown Press, New York, 1946.

7. Adams, Larry L. A Follow-Up Study of Indian Graduates of Union High School, Roosevelt, Utah, M.E., Brigham Young University, 1965.

8. Adkins, Roy L. A Study of the Social Composition and Educational Background of the Indian Service Teachers in the Aberdeen Area, 1954-1955. M.S., University of North Dakota, 1955. 9. Agogino, George. A Study of the Stereotype of the American Indian. M.A., University of New Mexico, 1950.

10. Ala, Viola. The Problems Related to the Assimilation of the Indian of South Dakota. M.A., University of South Dakota,

1949.

11. Allegrezza, Tore S. Historical Survey of the Changing Character of Indian Schools. M.A., University of Colorado, 1939. 12. Allen, Arthur E. The Education of the New England Indians During the Colonial Period. M.A., Brown University, 1961. 13. Ammon, Soloman R. History and Present Development of Indian Schools in the United States. M.S., University of Southern California, 1935.

14. Anderson, H. Dewey, and W. C. Eells. Alaska Natives: A Survey of Their Sociological and Educational Status. Stanford University Press, Palo Alto, California, 1935.

15. Anderson, James G., and Dwight Safar. "The Influence of Differential Community Perceptions on the Provision of Equal Education Opportunities." Sociology of Education, XL:3:219230, Summer, 1967.

16. Anderson, Kenneth E., et al. The Educational Achievement of Indian Children. U.S. Department of the Interior, Bureau of Indian Affairs, Washington, 1953.

17. Anduri, Carl E. A Study of High School Drop-outs. M.A., Fresno State College, 1953.

18. Armstrong, Robert G. The Acculturation of the Cheyenne and Arapaho Indians. M.A., University of Oklahoma, 1942.

19. Artichoker, John H. A Survey of the Problems Encountered by Students of Indian Descent in South Dakota Colleges. M.A., University of South Dakota, 1957.

20. Artichoker, John, and Neil M. Palmer. The Sioux Indian Goes to College. Institute of Indian Studies, University of South Dakota, Vermillion, 1959.

21. Ashe, Robert W., et al. Survey Report: Navajo Community College. Bureau of Educational Research and Services, Arizona State University, Tempe, 1966.

22. Atkinson, Darrell D. Educational Adjustment of Ute Indians as Compared to the Mixed-Bloods and Native Whites at Union High School, Roosevelt, Utah. M.S., Utah State Agricultural College, 1955.

23. Aurbach, Herbert A. (ed.) Proceedings of the National Research Conference on American Indian Education. Society for the Study of Social Problems, Kalamazoo, Michigan, 1967.

24. Austin, Wilfred G. An Educational Study of the Pima Indians of Arizona. M.A., Stanford University, 1932.

25. Ayers, Solon G. An Investigation of Vocational Education at Haskell Institute. Ph. D., University of Kansas, 1952.

26. Badger, Angeline. An Activity Program for Indian Children. M.A., University of Colorado, 1938.

27. Baerreis, David A. (ed.) The Indian in Modern America. State Historical Society, Madison, Wisconsin, 1956.

28. Bailey, John F. A Comparison of Good and Poor Readers Among Full-Blood Ute Indian Children on Factors Relating to the Home and School. M.A., University of Utah, 1965.

29. Baker, Joe E. Problems of Navajo Male Graduates of Intermountain School During Their First Year of Employment. M.S., Utah State University, 1959.

30. Balyeat, Frank A. Education in Indian Territory. Ph. D., Stanford University, 1927.

31. Baptist, Mary. Mission Schools in the Indian Territory. M.S., University of Oklahoma, 1923.

32. Barcus, Wallace F. A Controlled Study of Indian and White Children in the Sierra Joint Union High School District, Tollhouse, Fresno County, California. M.A., Fresno State College, Fresno, California, 1956.

33. Barnes, Findlay. A Comparative Study of the Mental Ability of Indian Children. M.A., Stanford University, 1955.

34. Barth, Pius J. Franciscan Education and the Social Order in Spanish North America, 1501-1821. Ph.D., University of Chicago, 1945.

35. Barton, Walter C. The Educational Experiences Inherent in the Construction of a Sioux Indian Home. M.A., Colorado A. & M. College, 1939.

36. Bass, Willard P., and Henry G. Burger. American Indians and Educational Laboratories, Southwest Cooperative Educational Laboratory, Albuquerque, 1967.

« PreviousContinue »